Midwest Water News

Covering the water that covers the Midwest

Great Lakes

The Lake Keeps the Memory: Why Algae Returns and Where a Great Lakes Town Looks First

Algae on a lake is a record of what the land has sent into the water, and towns can learn to trace those inputs before the next bloom arrives.

By Staff ·

Midwest Water News

Anyone who has seen a green film gather along a shoreline in late summer has probably asked the same question: if the lake was cleaned up, why is the algae back? The answer starts with a basic fact about lakes. A lake is not a bathtub that can be drained once and left alone. It is a basin that receives whatever the land around it sends, and that load keeps arriving season after season.

Circle of Blue's report on Lake Champlain looks at this pattern in the lake between Vermont and New York. Its headline makes the point plainly: after nearly a billion dollars of cleanup spending, the algae "keeps coming back." Champlain is not one of the Great Lakes, but the mechanics are the same ones that matter to lake communities across the Midwest, from inland reservoirs to the shorelines of the Great Lakes themselves.

Phosphorus is usually the lever

Algae need nutrients to grow, and in many freshwater lakes phosphorus is the nutrient that runs shortest. When more of it arrives, algae can multiply quickly. The phosphorus comes from ordinary places: fertilizer and manure spread on fields, lawn fertilizer washed off yards, soil carried away from farm fields and construction sites, stormwater that flushes streets and parking lots, and septic systems that are failing or poorly placed. No single source fits every lake, so a town cannot assume the cause based on what its neighbors are dealing with. It has to find the local mix, and that work is slower and less glamorous than a cleanup announcement.

Why the lake holds on

Lakes also store nutrients. Phosphorus that settles into bottom sediment can remain there for a long time, and under some conditions, such as low oxygen near the bottom during warm months, it can be released back into the water. This is why an improvement in incoming runoff does not always show up quickly in the lake itself. Old deposits can keep feeding growth after new sources have been reduced, which is one reason lake recovery is measured in seasons and years rather than in a single project's completion date.

Weather adds a second layer. Warm, still, sunny stretches favor surface blooms, and wind can push floating growth toward particular shorelines, which is why the same lake can look very different from one beach to the next on the same afternoon. A clear-looking surface does not prove that nutrients are low, and a bloom that has faded does not prove that the underlying supply has been cut.

Questions a lake town can ask

A useful starting point is to ask who samples the lake and what they measure. Visible algae is the outcome people notice, but phosphorus and other nutrients explain the inputs. A monitoring record that tracks only the bloom can tell a town when the problem appears. A record that also tracks tributaries and storm outfalls can show where the problem starts.

Ask which streams and storm drains carry the most water into the lake, whether the monitoring covers those points, how often samples are taken, and where the results are published. Ask whether septic inspections and fertilizer practices are part of the plan, and who is responsible for each piece. The answers do not need to be perfect to be useful. They need to be written down, dated, and easy for residents to find.

What it means at the tap and the beach

If your town draws drinking water from a lake, the intake location and the treatment process matter. Treatment plants can remove many algae, but odor, taste, and certain algae-produced toxins require their own monitoring and their own response. Check your utility's water quality report and ask how it handles algae events. If a beach or lake advisory is posted, follow it, and contact your local health department or your doctor with questions about exposure, especially for children, older adults, or anyone with a health condition.

Lake-wide advisories also do not tell a household what is in its own well or plumbing. A home that relies on private water may want to review its own testing schedule and its coverage for home systems and appliances, so that a problem in a nearby lake does not catch the family by surprise. The lake shows what the land has been sending. Your own tap shows what reaches your house.